Dr. Kant s Argument - 1060 Words

Savulescu’s argument also has some flaws in regards to his responses to a few possible objections he talked about. One objection that Savulescu responds to is the objection that genes are pleiotropic meaning they have different effects on different parts of the body (The Ethical Life, 454). The example given was that a gene that prompts depression might also be responsible for heightened creativity and productivity (The Ethical Life, 454). Savulescu s response to that was that we would have to â€Å"limit interventions until our knowledge grows† and we would have to do moreâ€Å"adequate research† before expanding the types of interventions (The Ethical Life, 454). The problem with that is that it requires experimenting and testing on children and embryos which would be treating them as a means to an end rather than an end in itself. Kant would agree and say that these children â€Å"exist as an end in itself, not merely as a means to be used by this or that wil l at its discretion† (Kant, 96). Savulescu is suggesting research on children and embryos in order to reach the goal of allowing genetic enhancement. He is using them as a means to his end result. This is a major flaw as Kant would argue that treating people as an end is showing them the respect they deserve while treating them as a means is just dealing with them so that they can help to achieve the person’s goal (Shafer-Landau, 174). Therefore, a child should never be treated as a means to an end to help reach a goal for eitherShow MoreRelatedThe Sunday Night Blues : A Case About 59 Essay1700 Words   |  7 PagesA highly credible philosophical professor named Dr. Gordon Marino, made an entire article arguing why it would be inadequate and unethical for someone to quit a job that is necessary in order to provide for something bigger than oneself, that working or indulging in comfortable positions makes people miss out on the traditional connection of talent and duty. In Dr.Marino s article, A Life Beyond Do What You Love, he creates an effective argument about the traditional standard of self-fulfillmentRead MoreA Life Beyond Do What You Love Essay1698 Words   |  7 PagesA highly credible philosophical professor named Dr. Gordon Marino, made an entire article arguing why it would be inadequate and unethical for someone to quit a job that is necessary in order to provide for something bigger than oneself, that working or indulging in comfortable positions makes people miss out on the traditional connection of talent and duty. In Dr.Marino s article, A Life Beyond Do What You Love, he creates an effective argument about the traditional standard of self-fulfillmentRead MoreUtilitarianism : A Philosophical Concept That Was Taught By John Stuart Mill931 Words   |  4 PagesJoseph Morrone Dr. Kaspar Ethics 13 March 2016 Utilitarianism is a philosophical concept that was taught by John Stuart Mill in which he explains that every person always act and make decisions that maximize their utility. Mill gave a clear explanation that utilitarian often aim at maximizing utility because it is morally right. All actions that individuals perform in their own initiatives are to make their lives better in the long run. This essay is aimed at explaining the way in which utilitarianismRead MoreAnselm s Argument On The Ontological Argument1614 Words   |  7 PagesStephanie Iwaszkiw PHL 101 Dr. Wiitala Final Paper In the Prologion, Anselm argues that God exists, otherwise known as the ontological argument. Anselm believes that â€Å"there is no doubt that something than which a greater cannot be thought exists both in the understanding and in reality (Anselm, Proslogion, 7).† In other words, we cannot imagine something that is able to be greater than God; it would be a contradiction to think being greater than the greatest possible being that can be thought ofRead MoreDeontology : A Sound Ethical Theory1312 Words   |  6 Pagesidea and making a choice as to which theory to adopt is also a difficult matter. Most people will not choose to follow only one theory, but will adopt a moderately benevolent acceptance for others platitudes and beliefs. Many theories have secure arguments and an outstanding amount of people who abide by them. There, however, has to be one that offers more ethical and logical sense than others, right? In studying numerous ethical theories, I have found one that, to me, makes the most sense to liveRead MoreRacism - A History : The Color Of Money1063 Words   |  5 Pagesdehumanized for the benefit of commerce and trade. Although slavery existed for years before the slave trade, the documentary illustrates it was the enslavement of Africans that led to racism and the color of skin was used to distinguish races. According to Dr. Barnor Hesse, Associate Professor of African-American Studies at Northwestern University before this time, skin color was not associated with racial attitudes before the colonial powers’ slave trade. He notes in the documentary, â€Å"The burgeoning tradeRead MoreDeontology And Utilitarianism : Values And Society First Essay1398 Words   |  6 PagesNahoum Abara Dr. Byron Willist PP-110-B 2/10/2015 Deontology and Utilitarianism – Values and Society First Essay Philosophy consists of two major theories which aim to deny and validate moral rules and principles: deontology and utilitarianism ethics. These two perspectives give philosophy its wide range of concepts and decisions to frame our lives, giving structure to what we believe is right and wrong. More often than not, these concepts bring argument to what has already been set in stoneRead MoreEthical Theories Of Ethical Theory1461 Words   |  6 PagesAlyssa Arias Period 4 Dr. Robertson May 10, 2016 Ethical Theory Throughout Christianity there have been many ethical theories that have contributed in the development of the current ethical theories. Ethical theory is used to help us  ¨do good ¨ and benefit us by creating a solution that is morally correct. Every ethical theory stresses its own distinct ideas which are: anticipating the consequences, and following his or her specific tasks on how to benefit to one another in spite of trying to achieveRead MoreDr. Stephen Laberge s The Art Of Lucid Dreaming Essay1048 Words   |  5 Pagesfounding thinkers of psychoanalysis, saw dreams as expressing â€Å"the language of the unconscious†; and (for them) it was through dreams that we came to work out our psychological struggles, or confront our most primal impulses. Still others such as Dr. Stephen LaBerge (author of â€Å"The Art of Lucid Dreaming†) see dreams as avenues for our continued conscious development—even when we are sleeping. Lucid dreaming (a term denoted by LaBerge) is the practice of becoming conscious in one’s dreams—withoutRead MoreCapital Punishment Is The Death Penalty Essay1504 Words   |  7 Pagesstill prevalent and utilized today. When the topic of the death penalty is brought up it is certain to bring up a discussion and both sides of the argument are often heard. After being presented with facts, statistics and the findings, you will be better educated on the death penalty and will be able to adequately take a stand on either side of the argument. T.S. 1,407 people. 1,407 American people have been executed since 1976. II. Body Cons Failed as a Deterrence Statistically proven that when